I did this page recently. It’s unusual (for me), in many respects. Here, have a look:

Everything is from the Studio Calico March kit, Garment District. This kit is odd in that I found virtually nothing I liked in the main kit, but I have used the add-ons so much that I re-ordered some of the patterned papers. But for many reasons (separate from my determination to USE THE KIT!) the stuff in the main kit just worked for this layout.
The design is inspired by Jennifer L’s layout in the SC member gallery, also using that kit, but mine ended up quite a bit different from hers. But since I started with her design, I really have to give her credit. (I’ve scraplifted her before. Funny, for that layout I also trusted the kit and used a whole bunch of elements I wouldn’t have selected or combined on my own.)
I had this layout in my head for weeks. It’s hard to explain what it’s “about” because it really doesn’t have a point, or a message. I heard the song, my husband told me my stepdaughter (ie his daughter) liked it a lot, and it struck me and stuck with me. (BTW I checked with her if she was ok with me doing the page and if she was ok with me posting it on my blog; she’s ok with it all.)
When I finally did it, the outcome was not exactly what I had in mind. I wanted it to be less linear and more free flowing; more shabby chic, more whimsical. I also wanted to stitch a border all the way around it, and maybe stitch on the squares with the song lyrics in them (this was why I wanted a sewing machine, but I don’t have one and my mobility is too limited to go to a friend’s house to use one.) I wanted the page to look something like this layout by Lisa Dickenson that I fell in love with months ago. (Her blog header, by the way, was the inspiration for my blog header, and she was very sweet to give me some guidance on how to do it.)
So I emailed the page to her (my sd) to have a look, with pretty much all the qualifiers that I mentioned above. She is an artist herself, and a very talented one. And here’s what she said (inter alia):
… all those problems that you're talking about, specifically, that it didn't work out exactly how you intended, that sounds pretty normal for an artist! ... yes you are an artist! Your piece will sometimes grow and go in directions that you may not want or intend but what all my art teachers keep telling me is that that is how things that are new and great happen. So next time if it goes somewhere else don't get frightened. AND ALSO, don't feel like you're not creative just because you get your ideas from already existing pages. Every artist does. Then they build on it and make it their own. So wah-la you are an artist.
Now I never once mentioned to her anything about art or scrapbooking as art or being an artist or scraplifting, but her comments really struck a chord with me. Made me think (I sure love to think, eh?): is scrapbooking art?
I think it can be. But what I do is not art. What I do is creative, yes, and hopefully pleasing to the eye, and maybe even a bit crafty, but I don’t consider it art, and I don’t need it to be considered art.
There are scrapbookers whose work I think definitely qualifies as art. Mou Saha comes immediately to mind. A lot of the layouts over at Studio Calico, especially those done for the design gallery, are very artistic, especially the ones that use the painting and misting and sanding techniques.
But I WAS trying to do something arty here. And I suppose the process is the same as the artistic process, especially as my stepdaughter described it above. So there’s some art somewhere in all of this.
What was amazing to me was that though there’s no real point to the page, she “got” so much of what was going on in it. Like the sewing stuff—she sews, and she discovered all the little hidden sewing references in the page which were both for embellishment and which were also symbolic.
So that’s the long story behind what some might see as just an ordinary (if a bit odd) scrapbook page. What I love is how much just doing a scrapbook page can engage so many different “things” and thought processes. It’s all so wonderful to me.